(281) 550-3232

Evolution in Random Tower Packings

Many important unit operations such as distillation, stripping and scrubbing rely on the proper selection of tower internals and packings for best separation. Tower packing creates a large amount of surface area to volume where the liquid-vapor mass transfer can occur. Furthermore, it increases the production capacity and the separation efficiency, lowers the pressure drop and carries high operational flexibility.

Packing of the 1800’s

There exist about 200 different types and sizes of random packing, with specific packing area ranging from 60-450 m2/m3. The development in tower packing began at the end of the 19th century with the aim of increasing efficiency and capacity. As early as 1820s, broken glass or glass balls were used as random packing and by 1850s, these were replaced by pumice stone or pieces of coke. A main drawback related to these early packing types, was its unpredictable efficiency.

Packing in the Early 1900’s

In 1914, the thin-walled metal cylinder called Raschig Rings were introduced. Its invention took into consideration the importance of void fraction and the surface area in relation to mass transfer. Later in 1930s, Germany and US started collecting data for packed columns using metallic and ceramic Raschig rings as well as ceramic Berl saddles, which got introduced during this time as well. These random packings are known as the first generation of random packings.

First-Generation Random Packing

Berl Saddles

Berl Saddles

Ceramic Raschig Rings

Raschig Rings

Mid-1900’s Packing

Up to 1960s, the use of packed columns was limited to small plants with column diameters of not more than 0.5 m. This was due to the properties of the first generation of random packings, which suffered from decreasing efficiency when column diameters exceeded 0.5m. The low efficiency resulted from the high tendency of maldistribution. The invention of Pall Ring, introduced by the BASF in 1950s and patented in the early 1960s, reduced the limitations associated with prior packing types. These had openings in the wall which improved packing area distribution, wetting, and distribution of liquid. These had higher capacity and efficiency and lower pressure drop than the packings described so far. With their partly open area in the wall, Pall Rings were the prototype of the second generation of the random packings. The latter generation was characterized by the improvements made on the first generation of random packings and the opening of walls. The third-generation packing was based on the standard packing shapes including cylindrical ring, saddle and sphere. The goal of the third generation was to remove as much of the closed wall of the basic shape as possible. In the late 1970s and 1980s, many packing shapes with relatively large open areas were introduced like Nor-Pac, Hiflow rings, Tri-Packs, VSP, Cascade Mini Rings and more. Most of the packings were available in all three different types of material including metal, ceramic and plastic.

Second-Generation Random Packing

Plastic Saddles

Plastic Saddles

Ceramic Raschig Rings

Ceramic Super Saddles

Ceramic Saddles

Ceramic Saddles

Pall Ring-Plastic

Pall Ring-Plastic

New development began in the plastic sector which eventually led to new plastic packing types. Many complicated shapes were constructed out of plastic which would have been impossible to make from steel. The plastic packing had a wide range of applications not only in chemical and process industries but also in air treatment, wastewater treatment, gas cooling and in other applications related to environmental protection. Among many types of plastic, Polypropylene is inexpensive and is most popular when temperature do not exceed 250 F or ranges from low to moderate. In cases of high temperature, other plastics should be considered. Generally, plastic pall rings are stiffer and resist softening more than other shapes because of their internal “arms“.

Second-Generation Random Packing

Nutter Ring

Nutter Ring

MACH Mini Rings

MACH Mini Rings

NOR-PAC

NOR-PAC

Tri-Packs

Tri-Packs

VSP®

VSP®
Mufaddal Motiwala

Mufaddal Motiwala

Position

is the Engineering Manager and founder of MACH Engineering, LLC, which he established in 2005 to provide specialized engineering and mass transfer products to the petrochemical industry. With over 25 years of experience in chemical engineering and process design, Mufaddal graduated from the University of Houston with degrees in Chemical Engineering and Computer Science. Prior to founding MACH Engineering, he spent 11 years at Jaeger Products, Inc. as a process engineer, designing internals for scrubbers, air strippers, and distillation columns. Under his leadership, MACH Engineering has built a reputation for delivering high-level personalized service and innovative solutions for complex industrial applications. Mufaddal's expertise spans process simulation, vessel fabrication, packing systems, and mass transfer products, with a particular focus on critical facility operations in the petrochemical sector. His commitment to customer satisfaction and attention to detail has helped establish MACH Engineering as a trusted partner in industrial process solutions.

Categories

Archives